Following recent news stories questioning the way food brands and companies are using the health star ratings, we asked you your opinions on the subject. We wanted to know if and how health star ratings affect your purchase decisions, and whether or not you think it’s a good idea.
Many of you thought that easy to understand food labelling was important and should be mandatory. Healthy eating is clearly an issue that is important to you.
“It gives the consumer the choice at least to be more aware of what they are buying and consuming.” “I think the food star system is an excellent start to letting us know what exactly we are eating.” “After all the consumer is paying for the product, more ratings and labels, please.”
While the principle of health star ratings is supported by many of you, there is plenty of skepticism about how it works in practice.
A large group of you feel that the star ratings do not measure the “healthiness” of foods satisfactorily. You are dubious as to whether foods classified as healthy really are, and whether the ratings are a true indication of what is healthy and what is not.
“I don't always agree with the government's take on what constitutes healthy food.” “I have some pretty strong ideas about what I want to eat, and I'm not sure my standards match those of the health star rating agency.” “Some high (very high) levels of sugar are found in foods marked healthy!”
An even more serious concern is whether food companies can be trusted to label their food accurately. Many of you believe that large corporations will undermine the ratings system through misleading labelling.
“Honesty still does not exist so we still cannot believe what these labels display.” “I don't trust food companies to be honest with their ratings any more than I trust a taxi driver.” “The ratings scheme should be set and monitored by a body like the Heart Foundation and not the food companies themselves as they cannot be trusted.”
Interestingly, the place of origin of the food you eat is as important to you as the ingredients and nutritional composition of the food. People are clearly becoming more aware of what they buy, what they eat, and where it comes from. With more and more information about food available online, food companies will need to ensure they are completely honest about their products if they are to keep the trust of their customers.
Last reply: 25th Jun 2017 /
9 replies /
Post by Cafestudy Admin
well all the labels are to confuse and make the customer buy. No matter what all packed foods contain more sugar. Glad that they have been some improvements with health ratings atleast people can easily opt for better options among and be careful to manufacture food with caution. Reply
Posted by: chickenman
Posted: 19th May 2016
lonestar says: well all the labels are to confuse and make the customer buy. No matter what all packed foods contain more sugar. Glad that they have been some improvements with health ratings atleast people can...
well said lonestar. too much emphasis is placed on marketing.
things that are considered unhealthy today are classed as necessary tomorrow.
processed food is seldom healthy. i eat what makes my body happy. portion size is more important that any "rating" Reply
Posted by: frannymanny
Posted: 23rd May 2016
I must admit I am not sure what the star rating means. I received a sample of instant oats with apple and cinnamon .It has a 4.5 health rating so I took it to my weight loss club. The leader pointed out the amount of sugar sodium etc and wondered what exactly the 4.5 was supposed to mean. Now I am confused too. I was impressed with the 4.5 and would not have questioned any further. Reply
Posted by: col
Posted: 19th Jul 2016
frannymanny says: I must admit I am not sure what the star rating means. I received a sample of instant oats with apple and cinnamon .It has a 4.5 health rating so I took it to my weight loss club. The leader...
My niece is a dietician with a doctorate in the science. When doing her thesis she discovered that the health star rating does not compare the product to all other foods, but only to products in that group, eg. cereals, chocolate etc.
Posted by: Anonymous
Posted: 1st Jul 2016
I don't think I have ever seen these "health" ratings. But I don't think they sound very trustworthy due to the other comments. Reply
Posted by: Anonymous
Posted: 17th Aug 2016
In some Coles brand stuff, there were this health star rating Reply
Posted by: Burnt Out Digger
Posted: 26th Oct 2016
Burnt Out Digger says:
I agree I dno't know whether or not these health star ratings are valid or if they are something that companies pay for and use as a promotion gimmick Reply
Posted by: Jodie32
Posted: 27th Dec 2016
The health star rating is a very big problem and unfortunately too many people believe what we are being told. Major companies promote the health star rating to get their products sold. It's scary that we are being told things like chocolate flavoured breakfast cereal and milk drinks are low GI and are a good start to our day. It's all rubbish. Major sponsors like Nestle and Coca cola have a lot to answer for. I look at the nutritional panel on the package for my information not the "health star" rating! Reply
Posted by: William Tell
Posted: 25th Jun 2017
William Tell says:
I too believe in companies such as the Heart Foundation instead of the star rating system. As a person with Diabetes Type 2 I would like to see the National Diabetes Association of Australia to become more actively involved with food products giving the diabetics of Australia more security and honesty for them in being more confident in the food that they buy and consume. Reply
Caféstudy is owned and operated by Edentify Pty Ltd
Edentify Pty Limited ("Edentify") is committed to observing the Australian Privacy Principles as set out in the Privacy Amendment (Enhancing Privacy Protection) Act 2012, which amends the Privacy Act 1988.
Edentify has adopted all principles set forth in the Australian Privacy Principles that govern the collection, use, disclosure, quality, security, access and correction of information that personally identifies an individual ("Personal Information"). This Policy Statement applies to all Personal Information that Edentify may collect, use and disclose, whether that information is manually or digitally processed.
Edentify recommends that you keep this Policy Statement for future reference.
1. What Personal Information does Edentify hold and disclose?
All Personal Information collected is required and used for Edentify's business purposes only.
Edentify gathers and stores Personal Information when an individual registers to become a member of Caféstudy, redeems their points and registers to Caféstudy Chat. Your participation to surveys, forums and mobile polls is voluntary.
At registration we ask members to provide Personal Information. This information is used for targeting purposes, so the member will receive appropriate online research invitations.
All data collected from surveys, forums and mobile polls is stored and can be accessed by Edentify employees, Edentify contractors and Edentify clients. The Personal Information we collect is not shared with any unaffiliated third party, unless it is necessary to respond to your questions, provide the service you have requested or to comply with applicable law. We will never sell your Personal Information to any third party not affiliated with Edentify without your prior consent, except in connection with the sale, merger, in whole or part, of Edentify, its assets or the division responsible with such services.
Any Personal Information that you transmit or include within our online forums may be viewed and used by others. We are unable to control such uses of your Personal Information and by participating in online forums you assume the risk that such Personal Information provided by you may be viewed and used by third parties.
Edentify does not actively seek to collect sensitive information (for example health information, or information about racial or ethnic origin or criminal record) unless it becomes necessary for its business purposes. If Edentify does have to collect sensitive information, it will do so in accordance with the Australian Privacy Principles.
2. Data Security
Edentify utilises reasonable and appropriate protections to ensure that Personal Information in its care is not misused or lost or accessed without proper authorisation. Access to Personal Information stored on Edentify servers is restricted to those employees, clients or contractors who require such access to perform a legitimate business purpose relating to the Services, maintenance, internal security or other related issues.
All Edentify employees and contractors, as a prerequisite for employment, are required to sign a strict and detailed confidentiality agreement in relation to the Personal Information that they will have access to.
3. Children’s Privacy
Edentify do not knowingly collect any information from any child under 14 years of age without permission from his/her parents or legal guardian.
4. Correction of Personal Information
Edentify takes reasonable steps to ensure that all Personal Information that it holds is accurate, complete and up to date.
Individuals should promptly notify Edentify if any Personal Information that we hold about them is incorrect or out of date.
5. Access to Personal Information
Members can access and update, amend or delete Personal Information at any time using their personal log in details.
Individuals seeking access to their Personal Information should contact Edentify directly. Edentify will process all requests for access within a reasonable time. In certain circumstances, we are permitted by the Australian Privacy Principles to deny requests for access or limit the access we provide. If we refuse or limit access to your Personal Information, we will tell you the reason why.
You may at any time remove your Personal Information from our list of active users. All unsubscribe requests should be sent to email@example.com and we will process your request within a reasonable time after receipt. We are not responsible for removing your Personal Information from lists of any third party who has been previously provided your information in accordance with this policy.
7. Acquisition, Merger or Bankruptcy
In the event Edentify, its Parent or any of its Affiliates or Subsidiaries is acquired by another entity, or merges with a third party, the Successor Entity will be bound to respect the provisions of this Policy, with regard to any Personal Information in its possession prior to the acquisition or merger. In the event of bankruptcy, the provisions of applicable law will apply.
8. Privacy Officer