Reality tv - is it a good thing?

It seems Cafestudy members are split when it comes to reality shows such as The Biggest Loser, Big Brother and the X Factor. You either love them or you hate them!

Says BigGazza - “There is no ‘reality’ in reality TV. It is all manufactured rubbish and I refuse to watch any of it.”

When it comes to reality TV, many of you express strong views against it. The feeling is that it is not about reality anymore, but about creating drama through forced situations, for example, deliberately putting together clashing personalities. So really, according to some of you, it amounts to nothing more than a case of bad acting. The most unpopular reality show in this respect is Big Brother.

Some of you even describe reality shows as the exploitation of vulnerable people, and the show which causes the most controversy among you is the Biggest Loser. You either think it is a good thing, motivating those who are watching it to take action and lose weight....or awful. LiviaVenus describes it as “body shaming,” disliking the way it perpetuates the view that a person’s worth is tied up in their appearance. Jellybean51 says “who wants to watch a fit buff man telling a large woman to push the pain and see her dissolve into tears and throw up....I think this is awful.”

You highlight a difference between reality shows where contestants are on TV merely for the sake of being on TV, and reality shows where contestants actually do something. Suzukisue says “I prefer reality shows that are interesting and informative, where I could maybe learn something, e.g. Great Australian Bake Off or Masterchef etc”

You have more time for these shows, in which contestants actually need to have a talent, as well as those which can be informative – e.g. cooking and renovation shows. And not everyone hates reality TV – for many it is a guilty pleasure! According to one or two of you, it’s uncool to enjoy watching them......but you do anyway!

Last reply: 21st Oct 2015 / 25 replies / Post by Cafestudy Admin



Posted by: mazzab
Posted on: 21st Jan 2014

mazzab says: I totally agree with you Jen, on all points.. I am so over the cooking shows as they are never for "Mr and "Mrs Average'.. I mean, what everyday family goes to the extreme of making gourmet dishes every meal??? NONE. Those who can afford it, would have their own cooks anyway.. I did watch some of MKR last year, just to see how far the Tassie father and son got but had no interest in the recipes etc.. Big Brother is totally disgusting (as is the "hostess').. Renovation shows are ridiculous.. Even most if not all, of the music / dancing shows are fixed or at least the way the voting is done is totally unfair.

You must sign-in before you can add your reply to a message. Click here to login. If you are not a Caféstudy member then click here.